CLOSE

Open Nozzle System vs. Valve Gate: Choosing the Right Injection Technology for LSR Molding


When it comes to liquid silicone rubber (LSR) molding, selecting the appropriate injection technology is crucial for achieving high-quality parts, particularly for directly gated components that do not utilize a sprue. The two most prevalent systems in use are **open nozzle systems** and **valve gates**. Each system has its unique advantages and considerations, making it essential to choose wisely based on specific application requirements.


Open Nozzle Systems

Overview

Open nozzle systems are characterized by their straightforward design, allowing for direct injection of LSR into the mold cavities. The gate size typically ranges from **0.25 mm to 0.7 mm** in diameter, depending on the part size. For larger components (weighing over 200 grams), the visibility of the gate location can be a downside, but the simplicity of the system offers notable benefits.


Advantages

-Maintenance-Free Operation: Open nozzle systems are regarded as virtually maintenance-free, reducing downtime and operational costs.

- Flow Equalization: During vulcanization, the open nozzle system allows LSR to flow back into the cold runner as it expands, acting as a natural equalizer. This can help mitigate filling imbalances in multi-cavity molds.

- Surface Quality: Since vulcanized particles are likely to remain attached to the parts, the risk of defects like pinholes is minimized.


Considerations

While open nozzle systems are generally reliable, they may require reworking after approximately **1-2 million shots**. Additionally, achieving optimal filling can sometimes necessitate adjustments in hold-pressure times to avoid short shots or excessive flashing.


Valve Gate Systems

Overview

Valve gate systems utilize a more complex mechanism, where a needle closes the gate before the LSR solidifies. This system is particularly advantageous for larger parts due to its clean gate area and aesthetic benefits.


Advantages

- Clean Gate Area: The valve gate system provides a clean and aesthetically pleasing gate area, making it ideal for visible surfaces.

- Precise Control: Valve gates allow for more precise control over the injection process, which can be beneficial in applications requiring high accuracy.


Considerations

- Maintenance Challenges: High cavitation molds (16 cavities or more) can lead to greater imbalance during injection due to the friction of multiple moving parts. Maintenance can be time-consuming, requiring specialized knowledge and tools.

- Filling Imbalances: Once the valve gate is closed, any filling imbalances cannot be corrected, which can lead to defects if not properly managed during the injection phase. This limitation can be critical, especially in high-speed production environments.


Challenges with Thin Membranes

Molding ultra-thin silicone membranes presents challenges for both gating systems. These parts often require the use of sprues or sub-runners to avoid issues like pinholes, wrinkles, and other surface defects. The thermal transition area between the hot cavity and the cold nozzle or valve gate body can harbor vulcanized particles, which may dislodge during subsequent shots, leading to defects in thin areas of the part.


Conclusion: Choosing the Right System

Selecting between an open nozzle system and a valve gate system depends on various factors, including part size, production volume, aesthetic requirements, and maintenance capabilities. For applications requiring clean gate areas and precise control, valve gates may be the preferred choice. However, for high-volume production with minimal maintenance needs, open nozzle systems offer significant advantages.


PACKSONMOLD utilizes both open nozzle and valve gate systems in full-scale production runs, ensuring that we can assist you in selecting the most suitable gating system for your specific application. Our expertise in LSR molding allows us to provide tailored solutions that meet your project requirements while ensuring high-quality outcomes.


For further inquiries or assistance in choosing the right injection technology for your LSR projects, please contact our team at PACKSONMOLD. We are committed to delivering innovative solutions that enhance your manufacturing processes and product quality.


Comparative Summary

 Feature

Open Nozzle System

Valve Gate System

Maintenance

 Virtually maintenance-free

Time-consuming maintenance required 

Filling Imbalances

Can be corrected during vulcanization 

Can be corrected during vulcanization 

Gate Aesthetics

Visible gate, may require finishing  

Clean gate area, ideal for visible parts

Part Quality

Lower risk of pinholes    

Higher risk of defects if not managed



Hot News About Injection Moulding

Recommend Injection Molding From Packson


Resources Products News